The team is stretched. Deadlines keep moving. People are doing their best, but everyone's running out of room.
Someone raises a concern about the pressure.
The response?
Maybe we need to build everyone's resilience.
There are worse suggestions. I work in human development, after all. I believe the capacities we build within ourselves matter enormously.
But I also think we need to be careful about the questions we ask when things become difficult.
Because sometimes the problem isn't that people can't hold enough. It's that we're asking them to hold too much.
And no amount of breathing, reframing or positive thinking will make an impossible workload reasonable.
First, resilience isn't the enemy
I don't want us to swing from one oversimplification to another.
Resilience is not a bad word. Learning to respond to challenge, notice our reactions and recover after setbacks can be valuable in almost every part of life. Developing psychological flexibility, self-awareness and emotional regulation can create more choice in difficult moments.
A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis of 101 studies involving more than 20,000 adults examined digital interventions designed to promote psychological resilience. Across the studies, the researchers found small favourable effects on mental distress, positive mental health and resilience-related factors.
That's encouraging. But the studies involved non-clinical adult populations, not exclusively workers, and they do not show that resilience training can compensate for harmful working conditions. The effect sizes were small, and the interventions and populations varied.
We can value those skills without making them responsible for everything.
Pressure has a context
Think about the last time somebody told you they were overwhelmed at work. What did you ask first?
Did you ask how they were managing their time? Whether they'd taken their breaks? Whether they were practising enough self-care?
Or did you ask what had changed about the work?
In the UK, the Health and Safety Executive identifies six areas of work design that matter for work-related stress: demands, control, support, relationships, role and change. These aren't simply personality traits. They are things organisations can assess, discuss and influence.
A person might have excellent coping skills and still be struggling because three roles have quietly become one. Or because every decision needs sign-off. Or because nobody has made it clear which of the ten 'urgent' priorities is actually the priority.
Individual capacity matters. So does the environment that capacity is being used in.
What happens when organisations change the work?
Research gives us a reason to look beyond individual training, while also reminding us not to overstate the evidence.
In a 2023 meta-analysis, Bes and colleagues examined controlled studies of organisational interventions aimed at reducing exhaustion, a central component of burnout. Across 13 studies, the pooled effect suggested a small reduction in exhaustion. Interventions that combined organisational and individual approaches showed a larger estimated effect than organisational approaches alone.
Promising? Yes. A universal answer? No.
The authors rated the overall certainty of evidence as very low, with substantial variation between studies and potential sources of bias. They called for stronger research.
What I take from that isn't that one intervention has 'won'. It's that changing work itself deserves at least as much attention as helping the individual manage their response to it.
The World Health Organization's 2022 guidance makes room for both: organisational action to reduce psychosocial risks, and interventions that support people directly. NICE guidance on mental wellbeing at work similarly considers the conditions organisations create, as well as support and training.
It's a both-and conversation. Not an either-or.
The hidden message in 'be more resilient'
Imagine being the person who has finally said, 'I'm struggling.'
And hearing, 'Have you tried becoming more resilient?'
Sometimes that's intended as care. It may come with access to a course, coaching or a wellbeing resource. Those can be useful offers.
But it can also land as: The demands are staying exactly as they are. We need you to become better at absorbing them.
That's where the language matters.
I'd rather ask: What is this person experiencing? What are we asking of them? And what would make the situation more workable?
That opens up different possibilities. Maybe the person needs space to rebuild confidence after a setback. Maybe there's a conversation they've been avoiding. Or maybe the work needs redistributing, the deadlines need resetting, or the team needs permission to stop doing something.
Often, several things are true at once.
Develop the person. Change the conditions.
At Return to BASE, I think about two connected areas.
Inner Fitness is my developing way of bringing together capacities such as awareness, values, psychological flexibility, regulation and acting on what we learn. BASE (Body, Awareness, State and Execution) is the practical developmental method I use. The integrated method still needs formal evaluation, and I don't claim it has already been scientifically validated.
Organisational Fitness asks what sits around the person: the decisions, habits, relationships, structures and expectations shaping everyday work.
A leader may need to practise handling a difficult conversation. The organisation may also need to stop rewarding silent overwork.
A team may benefit from learning how to recover after pressure. It may also need more realistic deadlines and a clearer way to prioritise.
That's not a rejection of personal development. It's a more demanding version of it, because it asks us to change something beyond the individual.
Three questions worth asking before the next resilience workshop
What exactly is making this difficult?
Ask people what is consuming their time, attention and energy. Listen for patterns across the team, not just individual stories.
What can we alter about the conditions?
Look at workload, priorities, decision rights, support, meetings and expectations. Find one practical adjustment rather than adding another task to everyone's list.
What would help people navigate what remains?
Only then consider which individual or team capacities would be useful to develop, and how to support practice over time.
These questions aren't a substitute for a formal stress risk assessment where one is needed. In the UK, employers have duties to assess and act on risks from work-related stress.
Maybe the question isn't 'How do we make people tougher?'
Maybe it's, 'What would make this work more sustainable, without expecting people to give up the parts of themselves that matter?'
Some people need support to develop their inner resources. Some teams need a different way to work. Most workplaces will benefit from paying attention to both.
I want us to keep developing people. I also want us to stop using that development as a reason not to change the conditions they're working in.
That feels like a much better place to begin.
For a closer look at the thinking and evidence behind Inner Fitness, explore the Research page. If you're supporting a team or a portfolio of founders, you can also see how we work with organisations.
FROM INSIGHT TO REAL WORK
What might need to change around your people?
If you'd like to think through a team challenge, your leadership culture or how you develop people while changing the conditions around them, I'd be happy to have a conversation.
Start a conversation